The First Amendment to the US Constitution protects the right to free speech and the freedom to assemble peaceably. The Supreme Court has recognized that First Amendment protections extend to a wide array of expressive activities beyond literal speech, including symbolic and physical acts like marches and sit-ins. While the First Amendment protects free speech, the government can impose reasonable restrictions on the time, place, and manner of expression to ensure public safety and order. This includes setting guidelines for protests to prevent disruptions.

Law enforcement is charged with preserving those fundamental freedoms, including in challenging circumstances of protest and counter-protest and in situations from facilitating peaceful demonstrations to addressing potential violence and ensuring public safety. It is also essential for civic education to foster an understanding of the First Amendment and its role in maintaining a healthy democracy.

A number of the other core practice areas—community trust and partnerships, mental health and crisis response, stops searches and arrests, and use of force— contribute to how agencies respond to mass demonstrations. For a balanced and comprehensive approach to fully understanding the First Amendment in the context of responses to mass demonstrations, one must acknowledge the challenges and nuances while emphasizing its vital role in protecting democratic values.

OnPolicing-BG

Resources Related to Mass Demonstrations Response

Visit the Knowledge Lab’s full resource index here.

  • Reset

Guidebook/Tool | 2023

Tactical Response and Operations Standard for Law Enforcement Agencies

  • Crime and Violence Response
  • Response to Mass Demonstrations

Guidebook/Tool, Webpage | 2023

Justice Department Fact Sheet on Implementing Executive Order on Advancing Effective, Accountable Policing, and Criminal Justice Practices to Enhance Public Trust and Public Safety

  • Crime and Violence Response
  • Community Trust and Partnerships
  • Mental Health and Crisis Response
  • Response to Mass Demonstrations
  • Stops, Searches, and Arrests
  • Use of Force
  • Officer Safety and Wellness
  • Public Transparency

Guidebook/Tool | 2023

NTOA Public Order Response and Operations Standards

  • Response to Mass Demonstrations

Article | 2022

The Conundrum of Domestic Violent Extremism

  • Response to Mass Demonstrations

After Action Report | 2022

An After-Action Review of City Agencies’ Responses to Activities Directly Following George Floyd’s Death on May 25, 2020

  • Response to Mass Demonstrations
  • Use of Force

Case Study, Report | 2022

Comprehensive Assessment of the Seattle Police Department

  • Community Trust and Partnerships
  • Mental Health and Crisis Response
  • Response to Mass Demonstrations
  • Stops, Searches, and Arrests
  • Use of Force

Guidebook/Tool | 2022

POST Guidelines: Crowd Management, Interventionand Control.

  • Response to Mass Demonstrations
  • Responding to Mass Critical Incidents

Report, Research Brief | 2022

Rethinking the Police Responseto Mass Demonstrations:9 Recommendations

  • Community Trust and Partnerships
  • Response to Mass Demonstrations

The information provided within these modules has been gathered from various sources, including consent decrees, research, and practitioner and department-developed resources. These webpage modules are intended to be a guide for departments to use to improve their Constitutional policing practices. Additional information and resources may be needed to implement the recommendations successfully. This resource is intended to be dynamic, and the Knowledge Lab will continue to update and add to these modules to provide additional and current guidance for departments.

Empowering Law Enforcement Excellence

A Beacon of Guidance at the National Law Enforcement Knowledge Lab

Explore targeted areas such as evidence-based de-escalation, responses to mental illness, lawful procedures, and fostering just, fair, and impartial police practices. Elevate your agency's performance and legitimacy with our guidance and support.